Accused Has A Right To Undergo Voluntary Narco-Analysis Test At An Appropriate Stage

In Amlesh Kumar v. State of Bihar, 2025 INSC 810, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, while hearing a criminal appeal, sharply criticised the Bihar High Court for permitting involuntary narco-analysis tests and conducting a roving inquiry at the bail stage. The case arose when the Appellant, arrested along with co-accused for allegedly kidnapping, subjecting his wife to cruelty and causing the disappearance (feared dead based on confessional statements of co-accused), sought regular bail. However, the High Court in its impugned order accepted the submission of the Police officer to subject all the accused and witnesses to narco-analysis tests, if required.

The Hon’ble Supreme Court firmly held that neither involuntary narco-analysis nor such unfettered inquiries are permissible under law. Taking this opportunity, the Court addressed two critical questions: whether a voluntary narco-analysis report can be the sole basis for conviction, and whether an accused has the right to seek and undergo such a test. Relying on its earlier precedents, the Court ruled that a voluntary narco-analysis report or information derived from it cannot alone sustain a conviction. Further resolving divergent views across High Courts, the Supreme Court clarified that an accused may indeed request to undergo a voluntary narco-analysis test, but this right is not absolute. Any such application must be examined by the concerned Court in light of the overall circumstances, ensuring free consent and adequate safeguards before authorizing the procedure.

Tags:

Let us help you!

If you need any help, please feel free to contact us. We will get back to you within one business day. Alternatively, if you're in a hurry, you can call us now

+91 9052538538
info@karavadi.in

Recent Case Snippets

Alternative Remedies No Longer Bar Writs: A Legal Shield for ‘Questions of Law’

Anup Koushik Karavadi1 & Naman Sinha2 Inception and establishment of ‘Writ’ Jurisdiction: Writ Jurisdiction in the Indian Constitution has been borrowed from the concept of prerogative writs under English Law and was vested in the Chartered High Courts prior to commencement of Constitution. The framers of the Constitution adopted the Read more »

Ambience Infrastructure (P) Ltd. v. Ambience Island Apartment Owners, (2021) 2 SCC 163

The Supreme Court held that the execution proceedings and original proceedings are separate and independent. An appeal under S. 23 of the Consumer Protection Act will not lie to Supreme Court against an order which has been passed in the course of execution proceedings. An appeal under S. 23 is Read more »

State of Rajasthan Vs. Televar & Ors (2011) 11 SCC 666

The Court observed that, even though the circumstances may suggest that the theft and the murder may have been committed simultaneously, it is risky to assume that the person in possession of the stolen item was also responsible for the murder when there is just recovered stolen property as evidence Read more »

Disclaimer

The Rules and Regulations set forth by the Bar Council of India under Advocates Act, 1961 prohibit Advocates or Law Firms from advertising or soliciting work through public domain communications. This website is intended solely to provide information. Karavadi & Associates (“K&A”) does not aim to advertise or solicit clients through this platform. K & A disclaim any responsibility for decisions made by readers/visitors based solely on the content of this website.

By clicking 'AGREE,' readers/visitors agree and acknowledge that the information provided herein (a) does not constitute advertising or solicitation, and (b) is intended solely for their understanding of K & A services. By continuing to use this site, you consent to the use of cookies on your device as outlined in our Cookie Policy.